Submission 3953

-------------------------------------

Author: Sarah Adams

Published: 2025

Genre: Romance

-------------------------------------

This book is handpicked by the IBC Editorial Team. If you are an author, publisher, or reader and would like to have a book reviewed by IBC, you may reach us at editorial@indianbookclub.com — we’ll be happy to review it.

-------------------------------------

Coming home is never just about geography. For Madison Walker, returning to Rome, Kentucky, means confronting everything she left behind — the expectations, the failures she has not yet made peace with, and the quiet, steady presence of a man who has loved her for years without ever expecting her to notice. After the culinary world in New York strips her confidence down to its foundations, an unexpected job offer pulls her back: head chef at a new farm-to-table restaurant, backed by James Huxley, her brother's best friend and the person she has spent years dismissing as background noise. In Your Dreams is the final chapter in Sarah Adams's beloved When in Rome series; warm, funny, and disarmingly tender, a story about the courage it takes to try again when trying has already cost you everything once.

-------------------------------------

Madison left Rome with something to prove. She was always the Walker who needed watching — the one whose ambitions exceeded her certainty, whose confidence came and went in waves that nobody else could quite predict. New York was supposed to change that. Instead, it has dismantled whatever she had managed to build, leaving her with professional wounds she has not yet admitted to the people at home and a hunger for a fresh start she does not quite know how to ask for. The job offer arrives before she has to. James Huxley, a quiet, dependable man who has always run Huxley Farm with his head down and his feelings carefully managed, is launching a farm-to-table restaurant on the family property, and he wants Madison in the kitchen. The offer is professional. His reasons are not entirely so. James has loved her for years with the particular patience of someone who has never expected that love to be returned, but now that she is back, proximity is changing the calculation. Adams structures the novel around the dual pressure of an opening night deadline and the slow dismantling of the professional distance Madison and James are both pretending to maintain. The restaurant launch gives the plot its momentum and its stakes — real ones, not manufactured — while the town of Rome does what Rome always does: notices, meddles, and cares in ways that are simultaneously intrusive and entirely welcome. Madison's arc is the novel's most demanding emotional journey. Her struggle with professional confidence is not simply career anxiety — it is rooted in a deeper fear about who she is when she fails, about whether she is too much trouble, about whether she is worth the risk she is asking James to take on her. Watching her work through that, in the kitchen and outside, is what gives the romance its genuine stakes. James, for his part, is everything the novel needs him to be: attentive in the way that matters, steady without being passive, and possessed of the specific kind of love that pays attention before it declares itself. The family dynamics — including a sibling feud that surfaces at the worst possible moment — add texture and emotional complexity, and the return of beloved characters from earlier instalments gives the series its satisfying sense of closure without overwhelming the central story.

-------------------------------------

"Failure and the fear of returning to try again": Madison's professional collapse in New York is not treated as a dramatic backstory and is an active wound that shapes every decision she makes in Rome. The novel understands that the hardest part of starting over is not the starting but the risk of being seen to fail again by people who already know you. "Quiet love and the art of paying attention": James's feelings for Madison are expressed not through grand gestures but through the small, consistent accumulation of noticing and knowing what she needs before she says it, showing up without being asked, remembering the details that most people would not bother to retain. Adams is making an argument here about what love actually looks like in practice, and it is a convincing one. "Coming home as an act of courage": For Madison, returning to Rome is not a retreat; it is the braver choice. The novel reframes homecoming not as settling but as the specific difficulty of allowing yourself to be known in a place where your whole history is present. "Family, expectation, and the long work of being seen differently": The sibling dynamics in the Walker family carry the weight of years — old roles, old patterns, the difficulty of changing how the people who knew you first understand who you have become. The resolution of those tensions, when it comes, lands with the earned warmth of a series that has spent four books building toward it.

-------------------------------------

James is the novel's most complete romantic hero in the series, not the most dramatic, but the most deeply rendered. His love for Madison is expressed in the texture of his attention, and the moments where that attention becomes visible to her are the novel's most quietly devastating beats. He is the kind of character readers will think about long after the book is closed. Madison's growth from the family's uncertain one to a woman standing in her own kitchen, on her own terms, is the emotional arc the novel earns with patience. Her early volatility, the defensiveness, the fear wearing the costume of competence, is written with enough honesty to be genuinely affecting rather than merely frustrating. Mabel — Rome's beloved presence, everyone's surrogate grandmother arrives in this instalment with more depth and history than previous books allowed, and it is one of the novel's most unexpected pleasures. She is the kind of character who makes you wish the series had an entire volume dedicated to her. The series farewell is handled with the grace the books have always demonstrated. The returning characters feel like genuine closure rather than fan service, and the sense that Rome, Kentucky, is a place that continues beyond the last page is the most fitting ending Adams could have given it.

-------------------------------------

In Your Dreams is the ideal final chapter, generous with its characters, honest about its emotional stakes, and warm in a way that feels earned rather than manufactured. Readers who have followed the When in Rome series from the beginning will find this the most satisfying conclusion imaginable, full of the people and the place they have come to love. Those new to Adams's work will find it accessible as a standalone, though the accumulated affection for Rome and its residents is something that builds over the series — the full experience is worth having. This instalment is notably more open in its romantic content than its predecessors, which is worth knowing in advance and which Adams handles with the confidence of a writer growing into every dimension of her storytelling. For anyone who has ever left somewhere trying to prove something, or come back somewhere trying to prove something different, or loved someone quietly for longer than was comfortable — this one is for you. Rome, Kentucky, has always been that kind of place. It is very hard to say goodbye to it.

************************

This review is part of the Indian Book Club’s editorial initiative to spotlight books that inspire, inform, and leave a lasting impact on readers. Every title featured is carefully handpicked and reviewed by the IBC Editorial Team to maintain quality, authenticity, and literary value. If you are an author, publisher, or reader and would like to submit a book for review, we’d be delighted to hear from you. Please write to us at: editorial@indianbookclub.com Our team personally evaluates each submission, and selected books are featured as official IBC Editorial Reviews on our platform.